PHILOSOPHY
Reptiliandude on Poverty, Personal Responsibility, and the Fairness of Flat Taxation
This discussion expands on Reptiliandude’s opposition to progressive taxation and wealth redistribution, contrasting his advocacy of a flat tax and limited government revenue with DankNethers’ argument that the wealthy should contribute a greater share to support those in need. Their debate develops into a broader disagreement about economic justice, property ownership, political authority, and the meaning of freedom. RD argues that modern financial institutions, corporations, and political leaders have created a debt-based system that resembles a new form of feudalism, while warning that humanity lacks the impartiality and administrative capacity to deliver justice through large-scale wealth redistribution. DankNethers challenges his position by distinguishing ordinary taxation from the recovery of wealth accumulated through exploitation and by defending assistance for people struggling to meet basic needs. Other participants extend the discussion to political corruption, corporate influence over elections, voter apathy, media bias, and declining public trust in democratic institutions. The exchange ultimately reflects shared concerns about concentrated power but sharply different views on taxation, economic fairness, and how a more just society might be achieved
PHILOSOPHY
Reptiliandude on Poverty, Personal Responsibility, and the Fairness of Flat Taxation
This discussion expands on Reptiliandude’s opposition to progressive taxation and wealth redistribution, contrasting his advocacy of a flat tax and limited government revenue with DankNethers’ argument that the wealthy should contribute a greater share to support those in need. Their debate develops into a broader disagreement about economic justice, property ownership, political authority, and the meaning of freedom. RD argues that modern financial institutions, corporations, and political leaders have created a debt-based system that resembles a new form of feudalism, while warning that humanity lacks the impartiality and administrative capacity to deliver justice through large-scale wealth redistribution. DankNethers challenges his position by distinguishing ordinary taxation from the recovery of wealth accumulated through exploitation and by defending assistance for people struggling to meet basic needs. Other participants extend the discussion to political corruption, corporate influence over elections, voter apathy, media bias, and declining public trust in democratic institutions. The exchange ultimately reflects shared concerns about concentrated power but sharply different views on taxation, economic fairness, and how a more just society might be achieved
Image: May the God be with them (Photo by Dulana Kodithuwakku via Unsplash)
Source: RD, "Just posting these here before incredulous mods delete them." r/InsurrectionEarth, Reddit, (22 July 2018) https://www.reddit.com/r/InsurrectionEarth/s/HficJTJuuR
Garbotalk (reposting exchange):
SS2907: You ever been poor, bro?
Reptiliandude: Yep.
But ‘poor’ will always be a ‘relative’ term.
That temporary situation was part and parcel with my arrival here on this shithole.
But hanging out with chronic losers whining about how unfair and meaningless life was just kept on reminding me of a bunch of pigs content with oinking in their own mud while someone outside their realm of influence fattened them up for slaughter.
Beware of those who offer up help at the expense of someone else.
Especially, if it’s someone who promises to take from the ‘rich’ and give to the ‘poor.’
Because, ‘rich’ is also a relative term.
SS2907: Thank you for the response, sincerely. I need to hang out with more people like you. It’s a strange transition seeing things from both sides of the fence between the rich vs the poor. Especially if both sides are part of your social group.
ACuriousHumanBeing: Well then, if that is the case, why do we care about the poor in the first place?
If poor is relative, why give a shit? About any of it.
Reptiliandude: Poverty breeds criminal activity both civil and political. The poor require a way out of poverty that isn’t blocked by those whose ambitions are predicated upon the votes of willful parasites, sexually dysfunctional lunatics, and wheelbarrow rabble rousers.
ACuriousHumanBeing: So the cure to poverty is not keeping those in poverty alive but giving them a means to climb out of it, and destroying barriers in their way. Basically, teaching a man to fish instead of giving him one.
An effective thing people do in America is incentivize people getting out of poverty by tax cuts, but the problem is they grow with those cute, and can’t adapt once things change. You make men rich not by keeping them in poverty, but continuing to help them get rich.
Instead of trying to help the poor stay alive, should we try helping them become rich, perhaps through employment and or investing? Instead of just giving them something, give them a way to give something, and contribute.
Reptiliandude: Or you could do what we do and that is to apply a flat tax. Oh, wait… those political whores in congressional garb would never go for that. Their power after all, is vested in the power to tax. And they are lawyers, when all is said and done. And you know how lawyers are… Always ascribing paperwork and pontification to the same laudable position as that held sacred to actual productivity.
DankNethers: What does a flat tax have to do with it?
Why shouldn’t we require those that who have more to give, give more?
And those that have nothing – a means to prop themselves up.
Reptiliandude: Why shouldn’t we require those that who have more to give, give more?
You do understand that a flat tax is based upon a fixed percentage of actual income, right?
Those who make more will pay more.
But the percentage would be the same for everyone, rich and poor.
Thus, it is fair rather than theft.
Progressively-scaled income taxes constitute an ultimately destructive act in that such a form of taxation is theft legalized via statute which penalizes achievement and stymies the resolve of productive people.
It also encourages laxness if no labor is required on the part of the person who finds themselves the beneficiary of said stolen windfall.
The same is true of these property taxes of yours.
Those who pay taxes on their property don’t really own it.
The government is demanding their cut of future equity disguised as a fee for the privilege of allowing you to participate in a shell game where you pretend to have some sort of autonomy.
What you’re really doing is paying the government not to seize your home so long as they get their regular cut from your investment.
This makes the entire notion of home ownership an exercise in mutually assured hypocrisy.
What free society can thrive when it’s foundations are laid in such a fast setting concrete of debt and lies?
Property taxes also penalize achievement.
Why don’t you simply pay a fixed rate ‘City Essentials Allowance’ that pays for law enforcement, fire fighting and public school costs?
Such acquisitions would cost roughly the same price as a cable bill and everyone pays into it for the privilege of receiving city services—again, at a fixed flat rate based upon the average cost of those city services: in this case, roughly divided into the population numbers (adult) rather than based upon one’s income or property value.
Stick with me, Dank… I’ll wring that counterproductive Marxist bullshit right out of you.
GrizzlyBearly: I wonder if our species is truly lacks the capacity and fairness to wield such justice. We may have people capable and fair, but the system attracts the most narcissistic of our kind. The corruption is so rampant, that the more honorable, fair, and just of our societies would never want to slide into bed with such snakes. That level of bravery is what we need; I just don’t know if that is what we deserve.
I enjoy these type of posts. I agree with the logic. Talking about it is the first step, but how do we fix it? I’m not looking for an answer served on a platter, but a discussion from this community.
DankNethers: I understand that you want to preserve RD’s words, but since this is a debate regarding opinions on taxes, I would ask that when you quote me you quote my entire argument
Furthermore, what looks like one response from RD is in fact two. I don’t much care whether you include my words or not; but please mark it properly. I did indeed have a rebuttal to him
Please understand that what you’re posting, in this instance, is a moral as well as political stance. I would hope that all of us can have our opinions properly represented here
Thank you
garbotalk: I’ll fix it. Been busy.
garbotalk (reposting exchange):
Danknethers: I know what a flat tax is, RD 🙄
I disagree with your assertion that a gradated income tax is theft
I recently read that three people in the US hold 50% of the wealth of the nation
THREE people
That is theft
These oligarchs that have made their money on the back of so many should not only pay a relatively larger proportion of their income for the people’s welfare, but also for their proportionately outsized influence in the direction of the body politic
And furthermore one must consider the relative value of money. $1000 may feel like a lot to a poor man; but to a man of great means it is a ‘drop in the bucket’
In the absence of charity, I believe it is the duty of the government to counterbalance greed and miserliness where possible. Those in wealth typically don’t abide by John’s dictate that “The person who has two tunics must share with the person who has none, and the person who has food must do likewise.”
I agree with you regarding property taxes, however, and would love to see a more honest ‘City Essentials Allowance’, as you put it
A man’s home should be his own
Reptiliandude: You clearly have lost sight of what constitutes a ‘king,’ Dank.
This charade of democratic rule has simply empowered other agencies to bypass the obstacles placed by blood royals and to introduce a ‘new and improved’ feudal system to a people bound to debt, and blinded by narcissism and consumption.
The bankers and merchant conglomerates rule unopposed now, save for show, as they actively undermine every ‘free republic’ they infest.
Look at the bourgeoisie, lauding honors upon illusions created to side-step statutes and maximize profit over the well-being of people and nation.
How one so easily deceived shouts of his own free will from the rooftops that corporations are people too.
And he does do with all the solemnity of a man saluting his flag and pledging his sacred honor to the Almighty himself.
And who stands against such madness?
Crybabies like yourself, blathering accusations of ‘theft’ and making foolish and pointless demands to take back the wealth they’ve obtained.
Such pointless notions are positively laughable.
Look at Russia and the Soviet/Capitalist cycle that occurred there and learn something for fuck’s sakes.
Therein lay the city of seven hills.
Your passionate cries for ‘fairness’ comes from pretentious blather written by idealists and idle people who’ve never put in an honest days work in their entire goddamned lives.
Had they actually labored they could at least be among those who joined unions to accomplish something… anything…
Eternal vigilance is the price of Liberty.
And that vigilance has been abandoned, the post left to rot.
All that’s left there are crows cawing all day long and leaving their shit behind them.
War, famine, and death shall follow these narcissists.
Out of this, Caesar shall return among the living having risen from an empire forged of both iron and clay.
The bloodline of kings shall once again return to a world that bastardized itself upon the alters of greed.
Hasten and prepare for this…
For the day draws near that you shall be unable to buy or sell save that you bear the contract of your own ruin as a mark sealed within your own flesh.
DankNethers: I trust you know what they say about those who assume, right?
Nothing I stated above should lead you towards the notion that my ideal system of governance would be a Democratic Republic such as the one betraying it’s decay all around me
Democracy, it seems to me, is best practiced at the local level, where it can more easily respond to local tastes
No, I agree that the benefit of autocracies are that no one or no thing may stand taller than the king
Most importantly those oligarchies that our highest court has deemed ‘individuals’
A ruling so ludicrous that one has to wonder what those justices were promised when asked to betray their conscience
But what this has to do with gradated taxes is beyond me
If a man can hardly afford his bread, I think it best we don’t take his lunch money
And if a man can fill a stadium with bread and still not feel a cost, then he should fill another stadium with clean water
Call me a bleeding heart or call me foolish, I really don’t care
Society rots first from it’s stomach
Reptiliandude: The strong arm of that system which enslaves you in order to support that false currency your species so desires, is that which taxes you progressively.
If you want to be free from their influence, take from the traitors in your midst the power to tax, rather than to steal the wealth of those who dwell among you.
-PNDR
DankNethers: And in this regard, PNDR and BCCHS are in violent agreement
Reptiliandude: Your problem, Dank… Is that you fail to understand the concept of ‘theft.’
The only wealth redistributed that doesn’t fall afoul that territory is that obtained through treachery.
Or, in other words, that corralled by those who caused a corruption of your currency in their attempt to seize the world through duplicity.
Your species is incapable of adjudicating such manners as you lack the administrative capacity and fairness to wield such Justice.
And, since this subjugated world has been out of sync since mass was imputed into it, you also lack the necessary grasp of the time needed with which to wield such retribution.
You see darkly, as through a glass.
You cannot slipstream, nor throw such as these in a pit without a floor to await the day in which they can vocalize their defiance or display a newly discovered humility.
But creatures likened unto my blood mother possess fractal vision and cannot be readily deceived through entreaties and falsehoods.
Your justice system, flawed as it is, could not handle the load in any measure of fairness without society sinking into the most reprehensible brutality and falling into yet another failed attempt at collectivism.
So you see… your proposals are nothing more than the blunderbuss of an ape in his cage, imagining that this world is his own to wield.
You are not the first ‘men’ to imagine themselves so.
Nor are you the first to gather their own bones together.
garbotalk: We live in a society in which the majority of people don’t vote. Many of those who do haven’t taken the time to objectively analyze those running for office. They either vote straight party affiliation, no matter who runs, or base their votes on 30 second sound bites heard on repetitive commercials ad nauseam.
Most times, I vote for the least of the worst. I haven’t been excited about a candidate since Ronald Reagan, and he had serious flaws too. But at least he was willing to hold the line, speak out against perceived wrongs using the bully pulpit of the Presidency as it was intended, to encourage and motivate. He generally had an optimistic viewpoint of where our country was headed. It was contagious.
Now I watch the news and get upset at the lies, exaggerations, politicalization of every single thing, take downs as a blood sport and the coarsening of our culture. It’s frankly depressing.
We are not being led with honor by anyone. We’re being manipulated to agree to enrich the corporations our leaders are beholden to, because we allowed corporate money to influence elections.
THAT LAW MUST BE OVERTURNED.
Until and unless that happens, we are no longer a republic, but a corporate oligarchy, or a corporate monarchy as RD refers to us.
GrizzlyBearly: I agree. If we are going to move to a just governance, we need to neutralize finance as the primary factor for being elected.
Our political system acts like everything is black and white, rather than acknowledging that most everything is a shade of grey. They take a handful of issues and use that to divide us. Encouraging people that prescribe to their party to support their issues exclusively.
I try not to get my news from television anymore. Its not that it is fake news, but it is spun news. Everything has a spin based on the political leanings. I try to go find a direct source for the facts if possible. Unfortunately, those sources can sometimes be compromised as well.
Do you think the majority of voter apathy is due to most being fed up with the corruption and chose not to participate or is it people are so self concerned, they can’t be bothered with considering who will be their oppressor?
garbotalk: I asked a millenium that. She said, “What’s the point in voting? It’s just going to be hacked or faked. I don’t trust that the elections are fair and honest. I don’t trust the government at all.”
I told her that we still have to try. Our ancestors fought and died for these rights. We can’t just sit by and watch them be taken away.
GrizzlyBearly: Yeah, I agree. Sometimes the choices suck. I don’t go by the mantra; you are throwing your vote away by voting by a minor party though.
I pray about it, do some research, and try to make the best choice possible no matter what the chances are they win.
